Adding Life to Years
Better days lie ahead, believe it
More than investing in renewable energy, more than extending health insurance to those who don't have it, more than ending the U.S. occupation of Iraq in a responsible manner, the first job for our new president should be to restore optimism. We need to believe that we can do whatever we set our minds to. Because it's true, we can.
I've been reading about some interesting research lately on the placebo effect. It's interesting and it's also timely, for reasons I'll explain shortly.
In one of the studies, scientists at the University of Michigan injected the jaws of healthy young men with salt water to cause painful pressure. PET scans were then used to measure the reaction in their brains.
At one point the men were told they were receiving a pain reliever, but it was actually a placebo or fake medicine. Nonetheless, their brains immediately released more endorphins, chemicals that act as natural painkillers by blocking the transmission of pain signals. Despite not actually receiving any painkilling medicine, the men with aching jaws reported feeling less pain.
In a separate study a few years ago, Italian scientists hooked pain patients up to a computerized morphine-injection machine. Sometimes the computer administered a dose of morphine without the patient knowing it. Sometimes a nurse pretended to give the morphine while the machine was administering a dose of the painkiller. The morphine turned out to be 50 percent more effective when patients knew it was coming.
I bring up these studies because we find ourselves in a time of great national anxiety right now. Consumer confidence suffered its steepest monthly drop on record in October, according to a Reuters/University of Michigan Survey. A Washington-Post-ABC News poll released in mid-October found that less than half of Americans believed they will have enough money to last through retirement, and twothirds feared for their family's economic future. Nearly nine in 10 indicated they were worried about the direction of the economy over the next few years.
According to the AARP, at least 30 percent of people are postponing retirement plans because of the economic downturn. Banks report that elderly customers, especially those who lived through the Great Depression, are asking to withdraw money from their accounts. In perhaps the strongest evidence of dwindling confidence in the financial system, SentrySafe, the nation's largest safe manufacturer, reported a sales increase of almost 50 percent in the three weeks of highest market turmoil in early fall.
With all this frightful economic news, it's natural for people to worry about the future and even worry themselves sick. But if the research cited above is correct, it's just as natural for us to feel better if we can make ourselves believe that better times lie ahead.
Abraham Lincoln may have said it best: “Most folks are about as happy as they make up their minds to be.” Almost by definition, if people feel the economy will improve, it will improve because they'll change their spending, investing and hiring behaviors.
My hope is that with the presidential election behind us, we'll see a rebirth of optimism in this country. As I type this column, Election Day is still two weeks away, so I don't know who won. But whoever it turns out to be, I hope he will follow the example of a successful presidential candidate from not-too-distant memory, Ronald Reagan.
Reagan took office in 1980. It was a time of surging inflation and high unemployment. More than 50 Americans were being held hostage in Iran, and most would remain in captivity until Inauguration Day. The public's mood was bleak. Polls showed people no longer believed the future would be better than the present, let alone the past.
Does this sound familiar? Whatever one may think of Reagan's politics and policies, he proved to be the right man for those times because he helped restore a can-do spirit.
More than investing in renewable energy, more than extending health insurance to those who don't have it, more than ending the U.S. occupation of Iraq in a responsible manner, the first job for our new president should be to restore optimism. We need to believe that we can do whatever we set our minds to. Because it's true, we can.
By the same token, a lack of optimism can be crippling. The same Italian researchers who conducted the experiment with the morphine-injection machine conducted a similar experiment with Alzheimer's patients who were suffering pain. Here they found no difference between covert and expected administration of morphine. Why? Because the Alzheimer's patients lacked the cognitive ability to expect a benefit.
Unlike people who suffer from dementia, we are subject to the power of our own expectations. Call it faith, optimism, wishful thinking or whatever you want, but it works.
(Lawrence J. Weiss, Ph.D. is director of the University of Nevada, Reno Sanford Center for Aging and an adjunct associate professor of medicine. He welcomes your comments on this column. Write to him at weisslj@unr.edu or c/o Sanford Center for Aging, Mail Stop 146, Reno, NV 89557-0146.)